Sunday, 18 June 2017

COMMENT GROUPS! Do they REALLY beat the Instagram Algorithm

Ahhh Instagram. I will never forget turning 18 and my friends introducing me to this new app and I really wasn't that impressed. I'm never a fan of change in general, and I was probably still missing the old times of Bebo and MSN (who remembers sharing the love, or having your best mates mentioned in your msn name?!) Gaahh sad times!  I genuinely didn't think Instagram would be MASSIVE, nor did I ever think I would be earning money through the platform and running my own mini business. But as most of us know, Instagram has changed everyones news feeds so photos are not in chronological order but in their own algorithm. Even I get confused talking about it, but the best way to describe it is like this:

Say you follow a celebrity and you also follow a work colleague. The celebrity posts something in the morning and the work colleague posts something 5 minutes ago. Instead of seeing the most recent uploads, you are more likely to see the Instagrammers that have a higher engagement or the ones you engage with the most. Hence why you may see a celebrity's post from the night before, but you never saw that cocktail drink which an old friend posted that evening! 

Most people still complain about this because although they like and comment on their favourite Instgrammers, they NEVER see them appear in their news feeds and they have to always search them to see if they have posted any new content. 

So what exactly is a comment group? 

A comment group, is just a group chat (in this case with bloggers and influencers) where someone is normally in charge (admin) who has the control to add or remove people, and all of us throughout the day will post our Instagram images into the group and we all have to comment on each others. Ideally you HAVE to comment on everyone else's photograph first and be up to date before you post your own image. Some groups would maybe vary on how many times you could post in a day (normally it was only once or twice a day), and if you didn't use the chat for many days you were at a high chance of getting kicked out. (By the way I'm going by my own experience and some rules may vary but the gist is, you help each other gain comments!) 

I remember being added to some last August just on the Instagram group chat. You can only have fifteen people in a group, but at the time I was all for it! So many people on Twitter were moaning about their likes and comments decreasing, and there has been constant debates whether it's better to switch to a business account or to keep it personal one.  At the time on Instagram I was in a couple of all girl groups (so thats 30 people). 
So for a couple of months I was happy to be using the Instagram chats for gaining comments. It was a little shock to the system, especially when you hadn't been on the chat all day and there were several notifications to get through, but I found the process highly addictive and it meant chatting to other bloggers. It was a case of 'I scratch your back, and you scratch mine'. We were all in the same boat and I weirdly got a buzz getting some extra comments per photograph. 
But over time, Instagram group chats were not enough, and many people were moving over to an app called 'Telegram', an app very similar to WhatsApp, but you could have AS MANY PEOPLE AS YOU WANT in a group. Again, me not liking change, I was one of the last to move over to Telegram and to give that a go. 

Now this is when things get fucking ridiculous. 

The most I was ever in on Telegram was four comment groups, all ranging from 50-100 bloggers/influncers. One of them I was in was strictly for over 100k followers because apparently 'your photographs reach out more to people when you have engagement from Instagrammers with higher followings' (this is apparently by the way, I've still not a clue, but I went with it). 
By being in these comment groups, you can't just upload a photograph to Instagram like a normal person. Instead your are getting through all the notifications beforehand (if you miss a day, you could wake up to at least 300+ notifications), commenting on everyone else's photograph which has been added into the chat (which I'm telling you now, can take OVER AN HOUR). Then finally, you can upload yours, and you feel a sigh of relief and you feel a little high out of seeing ten or twenty comments appear within ten minutes! Kerching!

The problem is, over time it gets really really exhausting and it was always really infuriating when you would comment nice and genuine words (apparently Instagram will only consider a comment genuine if it's at least three to four words, otherwise it's classed as spammy) and then others would comment 'Great shot babe'. Or 'Love this shot'. Normally there would be strict rules to not to post comments like this but people would still do it, as well as cheekily post their image into the chat saying they have 'caught up' with all the previous posts when they really haven't (they didn't get away with this for long!).

Over time, I think the quantity of the comments became less less and genuine and more and more spammy. I almost felt trapped because I knew that if I just posted an Instagram image without adding it to the group chat, the engagement would be rubbish on it, but I knew that if I caught up on the chat and posted my image, I probably still wouldn't be happy with the 50+ comments which I knew in my heart, weren't from my followers that genuinely WANTED to comment. 

So now it leads me onto this. Are the comment groups worth it? Do they actually increase your impressions and reach? 

About two weeks ago I decided to remove myself from all the comment groups and delete Telegram altogether. Annoyingly I can confirm that the comment groups DO HELP with engagement, but not massively. The photographs with the help of the comment groups had about 5k-10k more reach on average compared to my photographs now which are now getting NO HELP! This is the same for my impressions too. 

When I removed myself from the groups I did feel a little lost to begin with, but I know in my gut it is best and I would rather be genuine and engaging with any comments that I know are NOT from a comment group! I would rather ten genuine comments which I can personally reply back to, than fifty which I know are from other people helping each other and they don't always look natural.

Don't get me wrong if you are in a comment group I'm not saying they are all bad! I've interacted with some amazing bloggers and some of them are so lovely and have really helped with my engagement and some have posted really nice comments over the months. I've even been approached by brands that have seen my comments through other bloggers in the group!  If Instagram make things tougher then maybe one day I may join another again. But it will never be a massive one again! Life is too short and I would hate to know how many hours I have spent trying to get a few extra impressions.

 Instead I would rather focus my time on getting the ball rolling with Youtube where I can express myself to the full on there! 

So are you in a comment group? Has your experience been good or bad? Let me know

Follow me on 
YOUTUBE  / Instagram / Twitter
x x x x

Outfit details!! 

Top - Missguided
Shorts - Missguided 
Sandals - Missguided
Sunnies - Quay Australia on ASOS
Belt - ASOS
Bag (also comes in black!) - New Look



  1. I love Instagram but as soon as I think I've figured it out to get more likes and comments, something changes and it goes back down again. A comment group sounds like it would take up too much of my time.
    I'm trying not to think about numbers and post what I like and like and comment on others' images because I like them, not because I should :)

  2. I'm in about 5/6 different insta pods which I've found really helpful! But I feel it's the same people liking and commenting and not people from all over the place. I really don't get this algorithm thing, do you know anything about the shadow Ann or the hashtags thing? Please do a post if you do! This one was a big help!

    Isobel x

    New post:
    New Video:
    Bloglovin :

  3. I am in love with this top! Love the print! Thank you for this review! Great one!

  4. Wow i have never heard of these before but they sound VERY time consuming! Thanks for the review though its always nice to hear whats going on in the insta world...

  5. Some will disclose to you this is a decent method for misleading clients. Indeed, in all actuality as long as you keep advancing your business the correct way and offering your clients quality items, they will continue returning.use GFF and become famous

  6. SO your style of writing is unique i am going to follow you on instagram

  7. I'll review this blog as An and it demonstrates how much exertion has been put into this.
    Wanessa Angell Instagram

  8. Copygram is one of the such tools which focuses on the printing of Instagram photos, but when you clickon Here, one can get a cleaner view of his/her Instagram feed,along with the ability to like, tag and comment on the photos.Instagress or Instagram Bot

  9. Seeing a danger to its online networking strength, Facebook acted quick to kill its most recent rival. buy real instagram likes and followers

  10. It's great to use hashtags, just make sure to not lose control and generate too many in one post - deliver quality over quantity.instagram hack

  11. If you are taking the pictures with a camera, make sure the lighting and focus are right to get you the right photos you need to go viral on Instagram.

  12. Use Instagram to show off your product/service and even your corporate culture by capturing candid office instagram likes

  13. Trying to figure out how to write music to lyrics can cause some major writers block out. Plenty of people will be so hung up on finding a melody they get writers block. The songwriting just stops. song lyrics for instagram captions

  14. Instagram can be used to market almost anything, with a creative mind and a committed team, you can create quite the buzz around your brand!
    Instagram follower kaufen

  15. Hello ,
    Great informative post over here
    Amazing tips over here to raise a profitable blog from scratch. I am newbie, and love to learn how to build up my skill and these all great advise are going to work for me. Keywords are really cool idea to create so magical words and it attract to blogger.
    Social media is a great platform to develop marketing and these is very effective idea to promote business.
    Thanks for the share
    Buy Instagram Followers UK

  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

  18. I'm sure that Get Real Instagram Followers can also provide information about Instagram features and hidden tricks you can do to increase followers.

  19. You can likewise select to complete a live item audit video and offer it on Instagram. buyinstagramfollowers44

  20. Hy how are you this is so informative post thanks for share

  21. Dissimilar to Facebook and Google+ where you're required to set up a long individual profile before you can set up a brand page, buy Instagram followers uk

  22. This cool application lets you easily feature them across the board well-made composition.

  23. There was a nice info share on your post, Thank you for sharing and feel free to visit us at Cerita Seks

  24. It is important to use Globalwebsolution NicheRelevant Blog Commenting Service. When you comment on a blog, you create a backlink. This will take a group of targeted audience to your web page. If you are working in the business of cosmetics, you don’t want a group of teenage boys from a sports good selling web page to land on your page. It is highly advisable to look for blog sites that are similar to your niche and then post comments that will attract people who are interested in your niche.

  25. what must be noted is the time period in which it has managed such growth. It made its debut only in 2010; so, that is truly commendable. It also shows promise for future growth buying instagram followers

  26. Cool stuff you have got and you keep update all of us. buy instagram likes

  27. Some things are good. Some are great. Then comes this blog.
    buy instagram followers

  28. This is great! I think reading this, I loved every word. Seriously, keep posting the good information, bloggers like myself need it buy 100000 instagram followers

  29. You can also opt to do a live product review video and share it on Instagram. Pictures and videos are more appealing to many people than text files Buy real Instagram followers

  30. When you first upload to Instagram, you probably won't know to use tags. This is something that is true for everyone social media

  31. Buy Instagram Followers Get huge Community of fans to show the public your profile presence. Get likes and video views also. Quality Followers; No password required; Fast Delivery 24/7 support. Buy 10k Instagram Followers $39.99 only.

    Buy instagram video views

  32. Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking. escorts

  33. As a rule of thumb, you should endeavor to avoid taking irrelevant or trite pictures, which are commonly seen by people every day. In the word of Nick Bilton who works for the New York Times, (his Instagram account has more than fifty thousand followers) "people are more likely to admire you for quality over quantity - yes you may well take a fancy picture of your Starbucks cup but if I don't know who you are and your photo is generic, I won't be monitoring you. At instagram, "think quality" rules!

  34. or this one, you'll have to be creative-you can start by cross-posting Instagram content to your Facebook page, or riding on popular or trending hashtags Fast-Like US


© The Pixie Cut. All rights reserved.